| Date | Opponent | Score | Nation | Region | |||||
| * | 09/12/09 | SAINT FRANCIS (PA.) | L | ||||||
| 10/03/09 | MERCYHURST | W | |||||||
| 10/04/09 | WEST VIRGINIA WESLEYAN | L | |||||||
| 10/06/09 | at | Allegheny | W | ||||||
| 10/11/09 | LOYOLA (MD.) | W | |||||||
| 01/30/10 | WRIGHT STATE | L | |||||||
| 01/31/10 | at | Case Western | L | ||||||
| 01/31/10 | at | Cleveland State | L | ||||||
| 02/12/10 | at | IPFW | L | ||||||
| 02/13/10 | vs | Illinois-Chicago | L | ||||||
| 02/19/10 | JAMES MADISON | L | |||||||
| 03/11/10 | at | Buffalo | L | ||||||
| 03/12/10 | at | St. Bonaventure | L | ||||||
| 03/13/10 | at | Niagara | L | ||||||
| 03/19/10 | DUQUESNE | L | |||||||
| 03/20/10 | IPFW | L | |||||||
| * | 03/27/10 | SAINT FRANCIS (PA.) | L | ||||||
| * | 04/01/10 | at | Mount St. Mary's | L | |||||
| 04/02/10 | at | George Mason | L | ||||||
| 04/13/10 | at | Bucknell | L | ||||||
| # | 04/16/10 | vs | Wagner | W | |||||
| # | 04/16/10 | vs | Sacred Heart | L | |||||
| # | 04/17/10 | vs | Mount St. Mary's | L |
| Schedule legend |
|
# - Northeast Conference Tournament |