| Date | Opponent | Score | Nation | Region | |||||
| 09/12/08 | at | Carnegie Mellon | L | ||||||
| 09/20/08 | ALLEGHENY | W | |||||||
| 10/04/08 | Mount St. Mary's Invitational -- Emmitsburg, Md. -- 10:00 am | ||||||||
| * | 10/11/08 | at | Saint Francis (Pa.) | L | |||||
| 02/07/09 | at | Cleveland State | L | ||||||
| 02/13/09 | at | IPFW | L | ||||||
| 02/13/09 | at | SIU-Edwardsville | L | ||||||
| 02/14/09 | at | Eastern Illinois | L | ||||||
| 02/21/09 | CARNEGIE MELLON | L | |||||||
| 03/07/09 | IPFW | L | |||||||
| 03/08/09 | vs | Valparaiso | L | ||||||
| 03/09/09 | vs | Bethel College | L | ||||||
| 03/10/09 | vs | Washington College | L | ||||||
| 03/12/09 | vs | Connecticut | L | ||||||
| * | 03/20/09 | at | St. Francis (N.Y.) | W | |||||
| 03/22/09 | WEST VIRGINIA WESLEYAN | L | |||||||
| 03/22/09 | DUQUESNE | L | |||||||
| 03/28/09 | at | St. Bonaventure | L | ||||||
| * | 04/09/09 | MOUNT ST. MARY'S | W | ||||||
| # | 04/17/09 | vs | Monmouth | L | |||||
| # | 04/18/09 | vs | St. Francis (N.Y.) | L | |||||
| Schedule legend |
|
# - Northeast Conference Tournament |